Open your donor-advised fund at Fidelity Charitable if you want one that takes any amount to start and private company shares at no extra charge. If you’re starting small, giving shares held at Schwab, or putting in $25,000 or more at once, pick the provider built for that.
Whichever provider you pick, the tax rules are the same. If you itemize rather than take the standard deduction, you count a gift toward your deductions in the year you put it in, then recommend grants to charities over time. Giving stock that has risen in value, held more than a year, usually beats selling it and donating the cash, since the capital gains tax on the rise never comes due. The grants can’t get you anything in return, either. An IRS notice treats a grant that pays for your tickets to a charity’s event as a benefit to you, which brings a penalty tax on whoever recommended it.
We weighed each provider on what it takes to open an account and recommend a grant, its yearly fees and investment costs, the assets it takes, how fast grants go out, and who can take over the account. If you’re bunching several years of giving into one year so you can itemize, the fund holds that year’s gift while you spread the grants out.
Best overall: Fidelity Charitable
It makes the best starting point for most givers, since it opens with any amount and charges nothing extra to take private company shares and other assets that don’t trade publicly.
- What Sets It Apart: The nation’s top grantmaker by its count, with $18.3 billion in grants in 2025; the first national donor-advised fund program, started in 1991
- Investments: 25 pools; 7 asset allocation; 3 index (U.S. stock, international stock, U.S. bonds); 9 single asset class, money market among them; 5 sustainable and impact; the Charitable Legacy Pool
- Features: $50 minimum grant; recurring, future-dated, and anonymous grants; free iOS and Android app; successors can be people or charities
- Management Fee: 0.60% on the first $500,000, at least $100; 0.30% on the next $500,000; 0.20% on the next $1.5 million; 0.15% on the rest up to $5 million; quoted above that
- Minimum Deposit: $0
- Cost: Pool expenses of 0.015% to 0.93% a year; no extra charge for non-public assets; an intermediary charity’s fee on grants abroad
- Pros: Index pools from 0.015%; no extra charge for crypto or private shares; same-day transfers of stock held at Fidelity; free app
- Cons: $100 minimum fee, 2% on a $5,000 balance; a grant required every two years; stock from other firms takes about 2 weeks
For more information, read our full Fidelity Charitable Review.
Best for starting small: GoFundMe Giving Funds
A giver starting small pays no administrative fee here, opens with $0, and can add or grant as little as $5 at a time.
- What Sets It Apart: No charge to hold your giving, and $5 grants, where DAFgiving360 takes 0.60% a year and requires $50
- Investments: Four ETF portfolios built with BlackRock and Vanguard funds: Treasuries, Diversified, Stocks, and Sustainability; or uninvested cash; one portfolio change every 15 days
- Features: Grants to U.S. 501(c)(3) public charities, most within a week; stocks, ETFs, and transfers from other donor-advised funds accepted; successor named through support; GoFundMe app
- Management Fee: $0 administrative fee
- Minimum Deposit: $0 to open; $5 per contribution
- Cost: Fund expense ratios, unpublished before signup; card processing covered by GoFundMe for now, though its pricing page lists 2.2%; optional tip on each grant
- Eligibility: In the U.S., individuals 18 and older, businesses, trusts, estates, and family limited partnerships
- Pros: Grants from $5; no fee on stock, ETF, or donor-advised fund transfers in; most grants arrive within a week, it says
- Cons: No crypto, private company shares, or mutual funds; no public list of holdings or expense ratios; board can add a fee with notice; idle balances can go to a board fund after two years
For more information, read our full GoFundMe Giving Funds Review.
Best for Schwab clients: DAFgiving360
Schwab clients get the simplest way here to give shares held at Schwab, since the shares move online with no transfer form and the account has no minimum to open.
- What Sets It Apart: Shows beside your Schwab accounts, and shares held at Schwab go in with no transfer form
- Investments: 15 investment pools, from money market and index funds to actively managed and socially responsible ones, or an approved advisor’s picks from $100,000
- Features: Grants from $50, online or in the Schwab Mobile app; private company shares, real estate, and crypto taken case by case; up to 10 successors and 10 charities named
- Management Fee: 0.60% a year on the first $500,000, then down in steps to 0.10% above $15 million
- Minimum Deposit: $0 to open; $100,000 to have an advisor manage the account
- Cost: Each pool’s fund expenses (0.03% in the total market index pool); up to 1% a year for an advisor
- Pros: Online gifts from a Schwab brokerage account; Dec. 31 cutoff for shares at Schwab; fee scales with the balance; lower rates above $500,000
- Cons: 0.60% adds up on a large balance; no individual stocks without an advisor; other firms’ shares need a form and can take weeks; grant checks take 7 to 10 business days
For more information, read our full DAFgiving360 Review.
Best for families & crypto: Daffy
Families can share one fund for $5 a month on contributions up to $50,000 a year, with as many as 24 members, and it takes more than 300 cryptocurrencies.
- What Sets It Apart: A flat monthly fee set by yearly contributions, not the balance; more than 300 cryptocurrencies accepted
- Investments: 17 portfolios, from bond and stock funds to crypto; custom ones of up to 20 holdings from the $20 plan
- Features: Deductible the year you give if you itemize; $18 minimum grant, reviewed within a week; up to 24 family members; successors or charities named
- Price: Free below a $100 balance; $3 a month for up to $25,000 a year in contributions, $5 for family funds, $20 up to $100,000, $40 above; taken from the fund
- Minimum Deposit: $0 to open; $10 one-time; recurring from $10 a week or $25 a month
- Cost: Fund expenses of 0.03% to 0.30% on stock and bond funds; 2.9% card surcharge after the first card contribution up to $1,000; private stock sale fee
- Pros: Cheaper than a 0.60% fee above a $6,000 balance on the $3 plan; funds from 0.03%; $5 family funds
- Cons: No deduction without itemizing; fee rises with contributions, not the balance; costlier than a no-minimum 0.60% fee from $100 to $6,000
For more information, read our full Daffy Review.
Best for large gifts: Vanguard Charitable
Givers putting $25,000 or more in at once get pools built on Vanguard index funds and an administrative fee that drops to 0.11% on the part of a balance from $1 million to $5 million.
- What Sets It Apart: Pools built almost entirely on Vanguard funds, from 0.01% a year, and a fee of 0.11% from $1 million to $5 million, below Fidelity Charitable’s and DAFgiving360’s 0.15% to 0.20% there
- Investments: 36 pools: 6 pre-mixed portfolios, 14 index options, 12 active options, and 4 values-driven options
- Features: Deduction in the year you contribute, if you itemize; takes private company stock, real estate, and other complex assets; most grants out within two business days; up to two successor advisors
- Management Fee: 0.60% on the first $500,000, 0.30% on the next $500,000, 0.11% on the next $4 million, and less above that
- Minimum Deposit: $25,000 to open; $5,000 for each later contribution
- Cost: Fund expenses of 0.01% to 0.59% on all pools but the Private Assets Fund, at 3.38%; $250 each February under a $25,000 balance; added fees on some complex assets
- Pros: Index pools from 0.01%; lower fees above $1 million; most grants out in two business days; anonymous grants
- Cons: $25,000 to open; $500 minimum grant; $250 yearly fee under $25,000; 0.60% fee on the first $500,000
For more information, read our full Vanguard Charitable Review.
Fidelity Charitable fits most givers, and another provider here is worth choosing only when your gift’s size or the assets you hold match what it was built for. Move your gift in well before December 31 so the deduction counts this year.
Advertiser Disclosure: Many or all of the offers that appear on this site are from companies that compensate us, and some companies pay for sponsored content. That compensation may influence which products we cover and where and how they appear on a page, including the order in which they appear. We do not include every company or offer available in the marketplace.
Publisher: Source link








